The Truth About Carbs: Why Cutting Them Won’t Make You Leaner
Lynne Steiner • March 31, 2025
Introduction
Picture this: You’re on day five of your “no-carb” diet, powering through life with the energy level of a sloth on tranquilizers. Your brain feels like a fog machine at a bad ‘90s rave, and the sight of someone eating a sandwich fills you with an unreasonable amount of rage.
You were told that carbs are the enemy—that ditching them would lead to rapid fat loss and superhero-level abs. But here’s the plot twist: cutting carbs might actually be working against your goals.
Let’s break down why.
Why Slashing Carbs Can Backfire
1. The Low-Carb Energy Crash
Carbs are your body's premium fuel source. Think of them as the high-octane gas that keeps your engine running smoothly. When you suddenly cut them, your body slams on the brakes:
- Your muscles, which rely on stored carbohydrates (glycogen) for fuel, start running on empty.
- Your brain, which thrives on glucose, starts sending distress signals in the form of headaches, mood swings, and cravings that make you want to fight a croissant in the wild.
- Workouts become a sad, sluggish mess—like trying to run a race with cement shoes.
Sure, your weight might drop initially, but that’s mostly water loss, not actual fat. And once your body catches on? It slows down your metabolism like a turtle wading through peanut butter.
2. The "Carb-Free" Diet That Leads to More Cravings
Ever tried avoiding something only to become obsessed with it? That’s what happens when you banish carbs.
- Your body, craving quick energy, ramps up hunger hormones until you find yourself in a dark corner, negotiating with a loaf of bread.
- The longer you restrict, the greater the rebound—leading to late-night binges that undo all your efforts.
- Instead of achieving that “effortless fat loss,” you feel stuck in a cycle of restriction, cravings, and guilt.
This isn’t just willpower failing. This is biology. Your body is wired for survival, and when you deny it something essential, it fights back hard.
The Smarter Approach to Carbs & Fat Loss
Instead of treating carbs like the villain in your nutrition story, make them work for you.
1. Focus on the Right Carbs
Not all carbs are created equal. There’s a huge difference between:
✅ Whole carbs (sweet potatoes, quinoa, berries, legumes) – These are packed with fiber, nutrients, and provide steady energy.
🚫 Refined carbs (white bread, soda, sugary cereals) – These spike blood sugar, leading to energy crashes and cravings.
The key? Swap out the processed junk, not all carbs.
2. Use Carbs Strategically
Instead of fearing carbs, time them around your workouts for maximum benefit.
- Before a workout: A banana or some oatmeal will fuel your muscles and help you push harder.
- After a workout: Carbs replenish glycogen and aid recovery, making you feel less like roadkill the next day.
- At night? Yep, carbs before bed can actually help with sleep by boosting serotonin levels. Who knew?
Final Thoughts: Keep Carbs, Ditch the Fear
Carbs aren’t the enemy—misinformation is. If fat loss is your goal, focus on:
- Eating whole, nutrient-dense carbs instead of processed junk.
- Pairing carbs with protein and healthy fats for better satiety.
- Avoiding extreme restrictions that lead to cravings and metabolic slowdowns.
💡Action Tip: This week, instead of cutting carbs, try replacing refined ones with whole food sources. Notice how your energy, workouts, and cravings change.
Because at the end of the day, your body wants to work with you—not against you. And that sandwich? It’s not the villain—it’s just misunderstood.
More Posts
Walking into a globo gym can feel like opening a 64-count box of crayons when you only needed blue. Rows of machines. Endless options. A thousand tiny decisions before your warm-up even starts. That mental clutter is not motivation. It is friction. Why choice can slow progress Most people assume more options equal better results. In reality, too many choices drain energy before the workout even begins. Decision fatigue sneaks in quietly: What should I do today Is this safe for my body Am I doing enough Am I wasting my time By the time you answer those questions, your willpower is already tired. That is why consistency slips. What a coaching facility does differently A coaching facility works like a good GPS. You still drive the car. You still do the work. But you are not guessing which turn matters. We remove the mental noise. The plan is already built The workout fits into a bigger picture Movements are adjusted to your body and experience Progress has a direction, not a roulette wheel You show up. We guide. You move forward. Faster progress with less thinking Progress speeds up when the brain stops spinning. When decisions disappear: Workouts happen more consistently Effort goes into training, not planning Confidence replaces second-guessing Small, smart steps done repeatedly beat heroic workouts done randomly. Every time. Why this matters long term Fitness should feel like brushing your teeth, not solving a puzzle box. Coaching lowers stress, protects momentum, and keeps people training for years instead of burning out after a few months. Less mental clutter. More forward motion. Fewer stalled starts. That is the difference between a room full of equipment and a place built to coach humans. And that is why we are not an access gym.
Winter has a way of shrinking motivation. Dark mornings. Frozen windshields. Calendars that look like a losing game of Tetris. Yet somehow, some people keep showing up. Not louder. Not harder. Just… steadier. It looks boring from the outside. It is not accidental. They Stop Training Like It’s July Trying to train in winter the same way you do in summer is like wearing flip flops in a snowstorm. Technically possible. Deeply unpleasant. Consistent people adjust. They lower the volume before life lowers it for them They accept that energy fluctuates like a faulty thermostat They stop chasing “crushing it” and start chasing “showing up” Winter training is not about fireworks. It is about tending the fire so it does not go out. They Treat Missed Days Like Speed Bumps, Not Brick Walls Lots of people disappear after one missed workout. Consistent people do something different. They expect disruptions instead of resenting them They return quickly instead of restarting perfectly They see consistency as a rhythm, not a streak Missing a day does not mean the song is over. It just means you pick up on the next beat. The Winter Advantage Most People Miss Here is the quiet truth. Winter consistency builds the kind of fitness that lasts. Not flashy strength. Not dramatic transformations. The kind that feels sturdy. Reliable. Unshakeable. Like a house that stands through bad weather because the foundation was poured carefully. One Simple Shift to Try This Week Stop tracking how many days you train. Start tracking how quickly you return. That single mindset shift removes pressure, reduces guilt, and keeps momentum alive. Winter does not reward intensity. It rewards resilience. And the people who stay consistent now are the ones who feel unstoppable when spring shows up.
Every year, the CrossFit Open brings a mix of excitement and hesitation. A lot of people wonder if it’s really for them. Emily’s story answers that question clearly. Emily has participated in the CrossFit Open for over a decade . She has done it at different gyms, in different cities, and during very different seasons of life. No matter where she trained, she signed up every year. Not to chase the leaderboard, but because she loves the environment . What keeps her coming back is the energy. The cheering for friends. The Friday Night Lights buzz. The shared nerves, laughter, and high-fives after a workout. Emily is proudly a scaled athlete , and that has never been a barrier. In fact, it’s part of why she loves the Open so much. The workouts meet her where she is while still challenging her in meaningful ways. That same love for the experience is why Emily stepped up as a team captain for our in-house competition running alongside the HQ Open this year. She believes deeply in this community and in how powerful it is to do hard things together. If you’re on the fence, here’s what matters most: You do not need to be an RX athlete Any version of the workout, scaled or modified, earns points for your team You do not have to register with CrossFit Headquarters to participate in our in-house competition, though you are welcome to if you choose At CFR, the Open isn’t about being the best. It’s about showing up, being your best, supporting your people, and leaning into the energy that makes this community special. We’d love to experience it with you this year.
