Do You Need Supplements? The No-BS Guide to Protein, Creatine & More
Lynne Steiner • May 12, 2025
Walk into any supplement store and it’s like stepping into a candy-coated carnival of powders, pills, and promises. “Get shredded in 10 days!” “Sleep like a baby, recover like a beast!” “Unlock the secret your bodybuilders don’t want you to know!” Cue the eye roll.
Here’s the truth: You don’t need supplements to be fit, strong, or healthy. But could they help you? Absolutely. If you know what to look for.
Let’s slice through the marketing fog and take a real look at three of the most popular supplements—protein, creatine, and collagen—so you can decide what’s actually worth your hard-earned cash.
The Problem: Confusion, Hype & Wasted Money
We’ve all been there: standing in the protein aisle, reading a tub that says “ultra-hydrolyzed, triple-filtered, nano-particle isolate” and wondering if it’s legit... or if we’re about to buy expensive chocolate chalk.
Pain Point #1: Overwhelm & Confusion
When you're trying to build muscle, lose fat, or just recover from workouts without feeling like roadkill, supplements start to look like a cheat code.
But here’s what happens:
- You Google “best supplements” and find 17 conflicting opinions.
- You ask a friend, and they tell you to take 9 things before noon.
- You walk out of a store $200 lighter and still not sure if any of it works.
Let’s zoom in on what does work—without the fluff.
Protein: The OG of Recovery and Strength
Your muscles aren’t made of air. They're built from amino acids, and those come from protein. If you’re working out regularly and not eating enough protein, your body’s basically trying to build a house with no bricks.
Here’s when protein supplements make sense:
- You’re too busy to prep meals or eat enough real food.
- You train hard and need fast-digesting protein post-workout.
- You’re vegetarian/vegan and need help hitting daily protein targets.
What to look for:
- Whey isolate (fast, great post-workout)
- Casein
(slow-digesting, good before bed)
- Plant-based blends (for dairy-free folks—look for pea + rice combos)
And no, you don’t need a “gender-specific” protein. That’s just marketing nonsense wrapped in pink or black packaging.
Creatine: Not Just for Bros with Shaker Bottles
Creatine is the most studied, effective, and misunderstood supplement in the fitness world. People still think it’s some kind of legal steroid. It’s not.
What creatine actually does:
- Helps your muscles regenerate energy (so you can push harder).
- Improves strength, power, and recovery.
- Supports brain health and may even help with aging.
And here’s the kicker: it works for almost everyone—not just young guys trying to bench press Buicks.
When to take it:
- Daily, 5g. Any time of day. Doesn’t matter when.
- No need to “cycle” it.
Collagen: The New Kid with Skin in the Game
Collagen is trending harder than pumpkin spice in October, and for good reason.
- It supports joints, ligaments, and connective tissue.
- Can help with skin elasticity, nail strength, and gut lining.
- May be useful for older adults or anyone with creaky knees.
But remember: collagen is not a complete protein, so don’t swap it for your post-workout shake.
The Reality Check: Most Supplements Are... Meh
You don’t need a supplement stack that rivals a pharmacy.
Start simple. Nail your nutrition. THEN consider:
- Protein (if you’re not hitting your daily goal)
- Creatine (for strength, power, and recovery)
- Collagen (if joint support is a goal)
Conclusion: Supplement Smarter, Not More
Let’s cut the dramatics: Supplements won’t transform your body—but they can support the hard work you’re already doing.
Quick Recap:
- Start with real food. Supplements are support tools, not miracle cures.
- Protein: Great if you struggle to get enough through meals.
- Creatine: Proven to help nearly everyone.
- Collagen: Optional bonus for joints and connective tissue.
Helpful Tip:
Track your protein intake for 3 days. Just that. If you're consistently under 0.7–1g per pound of body weight, start by fixing that with food—or use a protein supplement to fill the gap. You'll see changes faster than with any magic pill.
And remember—if it sounds too good to be true, it probably tastes like it too.
More Posts
The Summer Slump Is Real Ah, summer. The season of sunscreen, BBQs, and totally losing track of what day it is. One minute you're meal prepping grilled chicken and doing early morning workouts, and the next you're eating popsicles for dinner while wondering if flip-flops count as gym shoes. If your routine took a vacation along with your brain this summer, you’re not alone . But here's the good news: fall is nature’s built-in reset button . Just like school buses return to the roads and pumpkin-flavored everything reappears, structure starts to make a comeback . And with it, the chance to rebuild habits that make you feel like a superhero who can deadlift groceries and still have energy for bedtime stories. Why Fall Works (Even Better Than January) Forget New Year’s resolutions and the guilt-drenched celery juice cleanse that follows. Fall has something better: natural rhythm . The days get shorter. The air gets crisp. Calendars fill up with school drop-offs, sports practices, and “how is it already Halloween?” moments. Instead of fighting the schedule, use it as scaffolding to build a sturdier routine. Think of fall as the supportive best friend who reminds you to eat real meals, put on real pants, and lift heavy things on purpose. Pain Point #1: Feeling Like You're Starting Over... Again If you’ve ever muttered, “I used to be in a good groove,” then stared into the distance like a war veteran remembering leg day...yep, we feel you. The truth is, you’re not starting from scratch. You’re starting from experience. You’ve done this before, which means: - You know what worked (early morning workouts before the chaos?). - You know what didn’t (meal prepping quinoa for the week when you hate quinoa). - You just need to dust off the basics, not reinvent the wheel. Fall’s structure gives you a framework , not a sentence. Lean into it. School drop-off becomes the cue for your workout. Cooler temps make cooking at home way more appealing than sweating over a restaurant patio. Pain Point #2: The All-Or-Nothing Trap Here’s the sneakiest lie your brain tells you: “I’ll start Monday. But like, a perfect Monday. With overnight oats, a gallon of water, and a five-mile run.” Spoiler alert: that Monday never comes. Because life isn’t perfect, and your routine doesn’t have to be either. Here’s the truth: - Showing up 3 days a week consistently beats going 7 days for one week and ghosting for three. - Chopping veggies while watching Netflix is still meal prep. - Walking your kid to school with a weighted backpack? Functional fitness, baby. Consistency wins. Every time. Especially when it’s built on a foundation of real life , not fantasy. So What Do You Actually Do? Start With One Anchor Habit Pick something that’s realistic, repeatable, and rooted in your current schedule . Some examples: - Commit to 3 workouts per week , even if they’re short. - Prep protein for 3 dinners , so you don’t panic and order pizza. - Get 7+ hours of sleep , because you’re not a college student anymore and melatonin isn’t a personality trait. Think of this habit as the first domino. Knock it down, and the others follow. Use the Power of Fall’s Rhythm You don’t need more motivation, you need momentum . Let fall’s patterns work for you: - Cooler weather = better sleep and more energy. - Shorter days = easier bedtime routines (yes, even for adults). - Set routines = easier to stack habits on top of things you already do. Example: Drop the kids off at school → drive straight to the gym. No thinking required. Just like brushing your teeth before bed, it becomes automatic. One Final (Practical) Tip Write this down somewhere you’ll see it: “Don’t wait for motivation. Build systems that keep you moving even when you’re tired, cranky, or just really want nachos.” Whether it’s scheduling your workouts like appointments or putting your gym shoes next to your coffee pot, set yourself up to win before the day even starts. The Wrap-Up Fall doesn’t ask you to be perfect. It just asks you to begin again, this time, with more wisdom and fewer excuses. So: - Let go of the guilt. - Skip the overhaul. - Choose one small habit that builds momentum. And remember: you’re not broken, you’re just out of rhythm. Fall is the season to find your beat again. If you're ready for more accountability, click the Book a Free Intro button and let's talk about how we can help.
You can white-knuckle your way through solo workouts all you want, but if you're still wondering why the results come in at the pace of a sleepy sloth, it might be time to stop playing lone wolf. Because here’s the hard truth: fitness isn’t just about grit, it’s about your environment. And nothing sharpens your edge like showing up to a community event where the air is charged with sweat, cheers, and the collective willpower of a whole bunch of determined humans trying not to die during wall balls. Welcome to the secret sauce of transformation. 🧨 The Lone Ranger Problem: Why Going Solo Slows You Down At first, training alone might feel empowering. You get to set your own pace, wear ridiculous socks without judgment, and dance during rest periods like nobody’s watching (because… they aren’t). But eventually, the music stops. Your motivation limps. Your fire fizzles. Why? Because progress thrives on pressure, and not the soul-crushing kind. The supportive, energizing, "let’s freaking go" kind. Let’s break it down: Pain Point #1: The Plateau You Didn’t See Coming One day you’re PR’ing your deadlift and grinning like a toddler on a trampoline. A few weeks later, you’re flatlining. That’s the plateau. The dreaded, soul-sucking Bermuda Triangle of gains. Why does it happen? - Because your excitement dries up. - Because every workout feels like déjà vu. - Because there’s nothing external lighting a fire under your glutes. But throw a community challenge or a partner WOD into the mix? Now you’ve got a reason to care again. Suddenly, you’re chasing more than reps, you’re chasing the thrill of the tribe. Community events shake the dust off your routine and remind you that fitness can feel like an adventure again, not a tax return. The Emotional Fuel Tank: Why We Stay in the Game Pain Point #2: It’s Hard to Stay Fired Up When You’re the Only One Clapping Ever try to celebrate a solo PR with no one around? It’s like throwing confetti into a black hole. 🎉 Now imagine hitting that same PR while your crew screams your name, your coach is jumping up and down like they just won the lottery, and someone brings you a high-five like it’s a trophy. That’s emotional fuel, and it sticks with you. In fitness, community is the charger that keeps your mental battery full. When you’re surrounded by others… - Your struggles feel less shameful and more shared. - Your wins feel less lonely and more legendary. - You’re reminded that you're not weird for caring this much, it’s human. And when you care, you keep showing up. And when you keep showing up, you change. Events Are Not Just for the Fit—They’re for the Becoming Too many people think community events are just for the firebreathers or the “already in shape” folks. Total nonsense. In truth, events are for the ones still climbing. They’re for the mom who's afraid to deadlift in front of people. They’re for the guy who’s coming back after injury. They’re for you , whoever you are, because everyone deserves to feel like part of something electric. Here’s what happens when you show up: - You meet someone who just went through the same struggle as you. - You get inspired by someone who was once where you are now. - You leave feeling like you're part of something bigger than just reps and sets. So What’s the Takeaway? You don’t need more discipline. You don’t need a new spreadsheet. You don’t even need a better playlist. You need people. You need energy. You need stakes. Community events bring it all. They give your workouts a heartbeat, your habits a rhythm, and your goals a context that actually sticks. They pull you forward when your willpower would rather scroll Instagram . And they remind you that fitness isn’t a solo mission—it’s a team sport disguised as personal growth. 💡 Pro Tip: Set One Goal After Every Event After your next gym event, set a " next step" goal inspired by the experience. Maybe you met someone who inspired you to get stronger at pull-ups. Maybe you realized you actually can do a box jump if you stop hesitating. Maybe you just want to show up more consistently. Whatever it is—name it. Claim it. Own it. Events give you fuel. Use it before it burns out. One Last Rep of Wisdom Your journey is yours, but it doesn’t have to be lonely. Progress happens faster, deeper, and more joyfully when you’re surrounded by people who get it. So the next time there’s a community throwdown, a team WOD, or a weird themed workout where you dress like a superhero for no apparent reason, go. Because those moments, messy and magical, are what keep you coming back. And that, my friend, is how you win the long game. 🏆 If you're ready to learn more about how we can help, book a class during our free community workout day on Friday, Aug. 29, or our free family workouts on Saturday, Aug. 30. Book those here: https://crossfitroselle.wodify.com/OnlineSalesPage/Main?q=Classes%7COnlineMembershipId%3D37282%26ProgramId%3D20304%26LocationId%3D3580%26IsToViewScheduleOnly%3DTrue
Your palms are sweaty (knees weak, arms are heavy... ope, sidetracked...). Your stomach’s fluttering like a hummingbird after a triple espresso. You’ve stared at the WOD list five times—and you’re still not sure if you’re more excited or about to hurl. Welcome to your first CrossFit competition. It’s a beautiful chaos—a swirling mix of barbells, adrenaline, chalk clouds, and nerves held together by neon shoes and community spirit. If you’ve never done one before, don’t worry. This post is your unofficial prep guide: equal parts pep talk, checklist, and secret decoder ring for surviving (and thriving) on comp day. Let’s dive in. #1: Sign Up With a Teammate (Even If You’re the One Who Drags Them There) You know what makes heavy lifts and high-volume burpees feel slightly less awful? Shared suffering. Doing your first comp with a partner—or even just having a gym buddy there to warm up, cool down, and nervously re-check the heat schedule with—makes the whole thing feel more like a field trip and less like a math final. - Accountability keeps you committed. - Shared wins (and fails) are better with company. - You’ll always have someone to hold your phone and take that victorious sweaty selfie. #2: Ask Your Coach for the Inside Scoop Your coach isn’t just there to yell “jump!” at you mid-clean. They’re a walking encyclopedia of comp wisdom , and they’ve seen it all—athletes forget their shoes, hit PRs mid-wod, and cry tears of joy (and quad cramps). Before game day, ask for help with: - Movement standards and how to prep for them - Strategy for pacing, transitions, and mindset - Tips for specific comp workouts if they’re released early Pro tip: Coaches love it when athletes take initiative. Show up with questions, and you’ll leave with confidence. #3: Keep Your Fuel Familiar (Don’t Eat Like a Pinterest Board) Comp day is not the time to experiment with that new beet-spirulina energy gel or your cousin’s homemade protein muffins. You want predictable, dependable fuel that won’t turn your stomach into a blender. - Eat the same breakfast you’ve trained on. - Bring carb-based snacks like bananas, rice cakes, or gummy bears. - Sip water with electrolytes, not mystery “performance” drinks with 87 ingredients. Think: “Would I eat this before Murph?” If the answer is no, leave it at home. #4: Pack Like You’re Going to the Fitness Olympics (Because You Kinda Are) Packing your comp bag should feel like a ritual. It’s not just about gear, it’s about peace of mind. A well-packed bag = fewer meltdowns and more focus. Here’s your comp-day survival kit: - Multiple outfits (you’ll sweat through the first two) - Snacks (see above: not your coworker’s weird homemade bars) - Water + electrolytes - Foam roller, lacrosse ball, or mobility toys - Headphones for zoning out - Flip flops or slides (give your feet a break between events) - Emergency extras: hair ties, tape, extra socks, deodorant, baby wipes Bonus item: A small towel to cry into or wave victoriously like a flag of sweaty glory. #5: Break the Day Into Bite-Sized Wins The comp might have three or four events. Each one has its own vibe, its own chaos. Instead of fixating on the entire day like an anxiety buffet, zoom in. - Focus on your warm-up and approach for just the next event. - After it’s done, reflect: What went well? What would I do differently? - Shake it off. Move on. You’re 1/3 of the way there. Repeat. The athletes who enjoy comps most are the ones who embrace each event like its own mini adventure, not the ones glued to the leaderboard after every round. #6: Soak Up the Vibe, It’s Part of the Magic CrossFit competitions are part fitness circus, part family reunion. You’ll see PRs. You’ll see tears. You’ll see toddlers in lifter onesies and 65-year-olds throwing down like it’s nothing. Smile. High five. Take it all in. You’ll remember: - The stranger who cheered you on during your last 10 wall balls - The DJ who played your pump-up song at the exact right time - The volunteer who counted every single rep and didn’t flinch at your death stare These little moments? They’re the real trophies. #7: Reflect Before You Scroll When the last event ends and the adrenaline fades, don’t rush straight to social media or start dissecting your performance on the drive home. Instead, take 10 minutes to journal: - What did you learn about yourself? - What surprised you? - What are you proud of? Maybe you blew your expectations out of the water. Maybe you stumbled, adapted, and kept going. Either way, you did the hard thing. Reminder: No matter how you placed, you’re already ahead of 99% of the population just by signing up. Final Thoughts: You Only Get One First Time Your first CrossFit competition is like a first date with intensity; it’s awkward, thrilling, messy, and exhilarating all at once. You’ll probably overpack, overthink, and under-eat. But you’ll also walk away prouder, stronger, and a little more addicted to the chaos. Helpful Tip: Want to feel extra prepared? Ask your coach if you can do a mock comp workout during Open Gym. Simulating the event will give you clarity and confidence before the real thing. So go ahead. Sign up. Pack your snacks. Trust your training. And most importantly? Have fun. You earned this.
