Do You Need Supplements? The No-BS Guide to Protein, Creatine & More
Lynne Steiner • May 12, 2025
Walk into any supplement store and it’s like stepping into a candy-coated carnival of powders, pills, and promises. “Get shredded in 10 days!” “Sleep like a baby, recover like a beast!” “Unlock the secret your bodybuilders don’t want you to know!” Cue the eye roll.
Here’s the truth: You don’t need supplements to be fit, strong, or healthy. But could they help you? Absolutely. If you know what to look for.
Let’s slice through the marketing fog and take a real look at three of the most popular supplements—protein, creatine, and collagen—so you can decide what’s actually worth your hard-earned cash.
The Problem: Confusion, Hype & Wasted Money
We’ve all been there: standing in the protein aisle, reading a tub that says “ultra-hydrolyzed, triple-filtered, nano-particle isolate” and wondering if it’s legit... or if we’re about to buy expensive chocolate chalk.
Pain Point #1: Overwhelm & Confusion
When you're trying to build muscle, lose fat, or just recover from workouts without feeling like roadkill, supplements start to look like a cheat code.
But here’s what happens:
- You Google “best supplements” and find 17 conflicting opinions.
- You ask a friend, and they tell you to take 9 things before noon.
- You walk out of a store $200 lighter and still not sure if any of it works.
Let’s zoom in on what does work—without the fluff.
Protein: The OG of Recovery and Strength
Your muscles aren’t made of air. They're built from amino acids, and those come from protein. If you’re working out regularly and not eating enough protein, your body’s basically trying to build a house with no bricks.
Here’s when protein supplements make sense:
- You’re too busy to prep meals or eat enough real food.
- You train hard and need fast-digesting protein post-workout.
- You’re vegetarian/vegan and need help hitting daily protein targets.
What to look for:
- Whey isolate (fast, great post-workout)
- Casein
(slow-digesting, good before bed)
- Plant-based blends (for dairy-free folks—look for pea + rice combos)
And no, you don’t need a “gender-specific” protein. That’s just marketing nonsense wrapped in pink or black packaging.
Creatine: Not Just for Bros with Shaker Bottles
Creatine is the most studied, effective, and misunderstood supplement in the fitness world. People still think it’s some kind of legal steroid. It’s not.
What creatine actually does:
- Helps your muscles regenerate energy (so you can push harder).
- Improves strength, power, and recovery.
- Supports brain health and may even help with aging.
And here’s the kicker: it works for almost everyone—not just young guys trying to bench press Buicks.
When to take it:
- Daily, 5g. Any time of day. Doesn’t matter when.
- No need to “cycle” it.
Collagen: The New Kid with Skin in the Game
Collagen is trending harder than pumpkin spice in October, and for good reason.
- It supports joints, ligaments, and connective tissue.
- Can help with skin elasticity, nail strength, and gut lining.
- May be useful for older adults or anyone with creaky knees.
But remember: collagen is not a complete protein, so don’t swap it for your post-workout shake.
The Reality Check: Most Supplements Are... Meh
You don’t need a supplement stack that rivals a pharmacy.
Start simple. Nail your nutrition. THEN consider:
- Protein (if you’re not hitting your daily goal)
- Creatine (for strength, power, and recovery)
- Collagen (if joint support is a goal)
Conclusion: Supplement Smarter, Not More
Let’s cut the dramatics: Supplements won’t transform your body—but they can support the hard work you’re already doing.
Quick Recap:
- Start with real food. Supplements are support tools, not miracle cures.
- Protein: Great if you struggle to get enough through meals.
- Creatine: Proven to help nearly everyone.
- Collagen: Optional bonus for joints and connective tissue.
Helpful Tip:
Track your protein intake for 3 days. Just that. If you're consistently under 0.7–1g per pound of body weight, start by fixing that with food—or use a protein supplement to fill the gap. You'll see changes faster than with any magic pill.
And remember—if it sounds too good to be true, it probably tastes like it too.
More Posts
When most people think of starting at a gym, the first emotions that come up are fear and intimidation. “Do I have to get in shape first?” “What if I don’t know what I’m doing?” “What if I don’t fit in?” At CrossFit Roselle, we hear those worries often, but the voices of our members tell a different story. Finding Belonging from Day One Kacie thought she had to be “ready” for CrossFit. Instead, she discovered modifications, coaching, and—most importantly—a welcoming group of people who reminded her she wasn’t alone. “I was terrified of CrossFit before trying it. I was surprised to find that I could do it.” Jess echoes that sentiment, saying what she loves most is everything: the low-pressure atmosphere, the owners, the coaches, the other clients. What surprised her most? Family events that bring everyone together. More Than Just Workouts Steph came from a background of mostly running. Lifting weights and trying movements she used to only see on TV felt impossible, until it didn’t. “CFR has pushed me out of my comfort zone… but the real surprise has been the community. Everyone knows your name. Everyone cheers for you. Even when we’re competing, people are still rooting for you to succeed.” Jenn remembers walking into gyms in the past and not even knowing where to start. “Decision paralysis” kept her stuck. At CFR, she found direction through our on-ramp program and structured workouts: “Even if you’re not doing the prescribed version, you’re doing better than nothing at all.” Life Outside the Gym For Amanda, workouts have changed the everyday stuff: lifting the 50-pound bag of dog food, carrying grocery bags, managing the chaos of kids and sports. “You don’t have to be in shape, or be a gym pro, or even know a single thing. Everyone is welcoming no matter your skill or level of workout experience.” Kacie feels the same—being able to move boxes, furniture, and heavy items while prepping her house for sale wasn’t just a task list, it was proof of progress. And Steph? She loves that her son gets to see her work hard, stretch beyond comfort, fail, and try again. “He’s learning that strength means persistence, and that it’s okay to fall as long as you keep getting back up.” The Truth About Starting No one in this group had to “get in shape first.” No one had to prove themself before walking in the door. What they found was a gym that meets you where you are, a community that lifts each other up, and coaches who make sure you never feel lost. And that’s what makes CFR different. Come see for yourself—click that Book a Free Intro button and get started today.
Picture this: your alarm goes off at 5:15 a.m. You squint at the clock like it just personally insulted you. The voice in your head whispers, “You could skip today. One day won’t hurt.” Now imagine this: you have a friend waiting for you at the gym. Suddenly, the pillow feels less persuasive. Why? Because someone’s counting on you. And that changes everything. Working out isn’t just about dumbbells and burpees. It’s about the invisible glue that keeps you consistent. And that glue? Accountability. That’s where the workout buddy steps in. Why We Struggle With Consistency Here’s the truth: most people don’t quit because the workouts are too hard. They quit because they’re alone. - Problem #1: Motivation dips. Starting a program feels exciting—you’re fueled by the novelty, the new shoes, the shiny water bottle. But excitement wears thin, and life starts throwing curveballs (sick kids, late meetings, Netflix whispering your name). When the buzz dies, showing up becomes a battle. - Problem #2: It’s too easy to bail on yourself. Let’s be real. If you promise only yourself you’ll train at 6:00 p.m., who’s going to notice if you don’t? You can shrug and say, “Tomorrow.” But “tomorrow” is where fitness dreams go to die. Consistency isn’t about Herculean willpower. It’s about designing your environment so skipping is harder than showing up. Enter: The Workout Buddy This is where the buddy system swoops in like a superhero wearing sweatbands. - Accountability built-in. If you’ve ever canceled on a friend, you know the guilt. It’s like eating the last slice of pizza when you promised to split it. Showing up for someone else pulls you out of bed in ways pure self-motivation can’t. - External motivation becomes momentum. Your friend is tired? You encourage them. You’re dragging? They text you “See you in 10.” Together, you create a rhythm that keeps you both in motion. The Power of “Showing Up” Think of your buddy as your fitness insurance policy. You might not always feel like working out, but you’ll do it because you made a promise. And promises are sticky. There’s even science behind it: studies show people who work out with a partner are more consistent over time. It’s not just about the calories burned—it’s about the commitment honored. And guess what? That consistency builds something sexier than six-pack abs. It builds trust in yourself. Every time you show up when you don’t feel like it, your brain takes notes: “I’m someone who follows through. ” That identity shift is worth more than any PR. A Quick Reality Check Does this mean your buddy is some magical unicorn who will drag you through every workout smiling? No. Sometimes they’ll cancel, sometimes you will. Life happens. But here’s the key: - You’ll cancel less often. - You’ll show up more consistently. - You’ll push yourself harder because someone else is sweating next to you. That’s the edge most people are missing. Pro Tip: Treat It Like a Meeting You Can’t Cancel Here’s your takeaway: put workouts with your buddy in your calendar like an important meeting. You wouldn’t bail on a job interview or a doctor’s appointment, right? Same rules apply here. And if you don’t have a buddy yet? Invite a friend who’s curious about fitness, or join a group class where the community vibe does the heavy lifting for you. Final Word A workout buddy isn’t just a companion—they’re the spark plug that keeps your engine firing when you’d rather stall. - Alone, it’s too easy to hit snooze. - With a buddy, it’s easier to hit start . So text your friend. Schedule the workout. High-five after. Laugh about the sweat angel you left on the floor. Because fitness isn’t just about reps—it’s about relationships. And the stronger those are, the stronger you’ll be.
You’ve seen them. The people grinding away for two hours in the gym—sweat dripping, headphones blaring, a shaker bottle clutched like a holy relic. And yet… six months later? They look exactly the same. Meanwhile, the person who swoops in, hammers out a 20-minute workout like a caffeinated squirrel, and bolts back to the chaos of real life— they’re the ones transforming. So, what gives? Why do shorter workouts often deliver bigger results? Let’s peel back the curtain and dig into the science, the myths, and the reality of training smarter instead of longer. The Myth of “More Time = More Results” Most people believe the longer they punish themselves, the faster they’ll see change. That’s about as useful as thinking you can cook a steak by leaving it in the pan for five hours. Here’s the truth: - Your body doesn’t care about the clock. It cares about stress, intensity, and adaptation. - Fatigue is a sneaky thief. The longer you go, the sloppier your form, the weaker your output, the higher the risk of injury. - Motivation has an expiration date. Long, repetitive workouts become mental torture chambers, and boredom is the silent killer of consistency. When you try to “out-time” your fitness, you lose the real game. Pain Point #1: The Calorie Burn Illusion You’ve probably heard the old line: “Just spend an hour on the treadmill and you’ll melt fat.” Here’s the problem: after about 30 minutes, your body becomes an efficiency machine. It adapts, conserving energy like a Prius coasting down a hill. Translation? You burn fewer calories the longer you go. Now, contrast that with high-intensity intervals or CrossFit-style workouts: - Short, all-out bursts spike your metabolism. Your body burns calories during and after your workout. - You recruit more muscle fibers. Which means more growth, more strength, more resilience. - You save time. Because let’s be honest—no one dreams about spending an extra hour staring at the gym wall. Think of it this way: a blowtorch (short and hot) will sear results faster than a candle that burns all day but barely melts butter. Pain Point #2: The Mental Burnout Trap Even if long workouts did work, let’s face it: who actually wants to do them? You’re juggling work, kids, a dog that needs walking, and a car that mysteriously smells like old French fries. The idea of carving out two hours for the gym feels like scheduling a vacation to Mars. When workouts are too long: - You procrastinate. “I don’t have two hours, so I’ll just skip today.” - You dread the grind. Exercise becomes punishment instead of empowerment. - You burn out. Eventually, the motivation tank runs dry. Short workouts, on the other hand, fit into your life . They’re quick wins. They leave you energized, not annihilated. They’re like espresso shots for your fitness—small, strong, and guaranteed to wake you up. The Science: Why Short Works This isn’t just motivational fluff. Research backs it up: - High-Intensity Interval Training improves cardiovascular health as much as, if not more than, traditional long cardio. - Short resistance training sessions build muscle when structured with compound movements (think squats, presses, rows). - Consistency trumps everything. You’re far more likely to stick with short, doable workouts week after week. Physiology loves efficiency. Your muscles, heart, and lungs don’t need you to sacrifice hours—they need you to challenge them with purpose. Helpful Tip: Try an EMOM or AMRAP Want to experience the magic? Here’s a no-equipment example: 20-Minute AMRAP (As Many Rounds As Possible): - 10 push-ups - 15 air squats - 20 sit-ups Go hard. Rest only as needed. See how many rounds you can hammer out in 20 minutes. You’ll be amazed at how cooked you feel afterward—and how little time it took. Or, try an EMOM (Every Minute on the Minute): - Minute 1: 12 kettlebell swings - Minute 2: 10 burpees - Repeat for 12–15 minutes Fast. Focused. Brutally effective. Wrapping It Up: Short, Sharp, and Sustainable Here’s the bottom line: - Longer doesn’t mean better. - Short, focused workouts give you more bang for your buck. - The key to lasting results is effort + consistency, not hours on a clock. So the next time you think you need to spend half your life in the gym, remember this: it’s not about how long you train, it’s about how hard you work in the time you have. Short workouts aren’t the compromise. They’re the secret weapon.
