Mental Reps: Why Grit Beats Motivation—Lessons from CrossFit That Apply to Real Life
Lynne Steiner • May 5, 2025
Motivation is a cupcake. Grit is the fork.
Let’s get this out of the way: motivation is flaky. It’s that friend who hypes you up on Sunday night and ghosts you Monday morning when the alarm goes off at 5 a.m.
Grit? Grit’s the one waiting at the gym with chalked hands and a dead stare, already halfway through warm-ups.
If you’ve ever felt the fire to start something—a workout, a new routine, a big life change—but fizzled out when things got tough, you’re not alone. Most people mistake motivation for the secret sauce. In reality, it’s just the garnish.
The real magic? Grit. And you can train it—rep by sweaty rep—inside a CrossFit gym.
CrossFit: The Reps You Don’t See
Here’s the thing about CrossFit: yes, it will turn your quads into concrete. Yes, it will make you Google “why do my shins feel like knives after double-unders.” But more than anything…
It trains your brain to stay when you want to run.
Every WOD is a controlled disaster. You’re facing a wall of reps, a timer ticking like a bomb, and your inner critic whispering, “You could just stop now. No one would notice.”
And yet—you keep going.
That’s grit in action. Let’s look at two ways CrossFit secretly rewires your brain to build mental toughness.
1. Motivation waits. Grit shows up.
Ever heard someone say they’re “waiting to feel ready”? It’s adorable.
Motivation is like a toddler: excitable, erratic, and likely to disappear the moment things get messy. Waiting for motivation to strike before taking action is like waiting for a unicorn to pick you up for work.
CrossFit doesn’t give you time to overthink. It gives you a clock, a whiteboard, and a choice:
Show up... or don’t.
But here’s what happens when you show up even when you’re tired, sore, or mentally checked out:
- You prove to yourself that action doesn’t require feelings first.
- You train the muscle of consistency over time, not just hype in the moment.
- You build a habit of doing hard things without an applause track.
Each rep becomes a vote for the kind of person you are becoming.
And spoiler: that person? They don’t quit on day two.
2. Quitting becomes a habit—unless you train otherwise
Let’s talk about quitting.
Not the big dramatic kind where you yell “I’M OUT!” and storm out of a gym (though props for drama if you’ve done that). I’m talking about the micro-quits:
- Dropping the bar with 3 reps to go
- Taking an “extra” water break mid-round
- Scaling back because it’s hard, not because it’s smart
These little decisions stack like bricks, slowly building a wall between you and the person you want to become.
Here’s where CrossFit flips the script:
You learn to recognize that critical moment—the “I could quit right now” moment—and choose otherwise.
You:
- Dig for one more rep
- Breathe instead of bail
- Let failure happen, then go again
And over time, those mental reps become your default—in the gym and out. You’re less likely to ghost on goals, cave under pressure, or let a bad moment define your day.
Because you’ve been there before, in box jumps and wall balls and farmer carries that make your hands feel like lava mittens.
The takeaway: Grit is trained, not inherited
Forget talent. Forget luck. Forget someone else’s highlight reel on Instagram.
Grit is a muscle. And like every muscle, it needs resistance.
That resistance is what you find in a hard workout:
- The voice that says stop
- The legs that want to give out
- The weight that feels too heavy—until it doesn’t
You train your body and mind at the same time. And that transfer of grit goes way beyond the gym:
- Showing up to a tough job even when you’d rather not
- Holding your ground during hard conversations
- Sticking to your goals when the novelty wears off and no one’s clapping
Want to build more grit? Try this mental rep:
Here’s a mental workout for your next WOD—and your next hard moment in life:
Set a mental goal before you begin.
Not a performance goal like “beat my PR” or “finish under 10 minutes.”
A grit goal, like:
- No negative self-talk during the metcon
- Take exactly one deep breath before every barbell touch
- Don’t stop moving, no matter how slow
This rewires your brain to prioritize presence over perfection—and that’s where grit is born.
TL;DR: Show up. Do the rep. Don’t wait to feel like it.
Grit isn’t about being fearless. It’s about doing the thing even though you’re scared, sore, or skeptical.
And every time you do, you become harder to break—in and out of the gym.
So the next time life throws a wrench, remember:
You’ve already done 21-15-9 of pain.
You’ve already fought the voice that said “nope.”
You’ve already finished a workout that felt impossible at minute two.
You’ve trained for this.
Now go do the rep.
More Posts
Heat vs Hydration: The Summer Struggle You Can’t Ignore You’re halfway through your workout, crushing those dumbbell snatches like a boss… and then—bam! A sudden wave of dizziness. Legs feel like spaghetti. Mouth drier than your sense of humor at a 6am WOD. If summer training feels like being roasted on a spit, this one’s for you. Because in the battle of heat vs hydration, most people are showing up to the front lines with a squirt gun. Let’s fix that. Your Sweat is Telling You Something. Are You Listening? We love sweat. It’s like your body’s internal fire alarm—shouting, “Hey! We’re overheating!” But the more you sweat, the more water and electrolytes you lose, and the quicker you start to fizzle out like a sad Fourth of July sparkler. Here’s the kicker: you can lose 1–2 liters of fluid per hour in hot, humid conditions. That’s basically an entire blender bottle... gone. So why do so many people still treat hydration like an optional side quest? Because we think water = hydration. And it doesn’t. At least, not entirely. Water Alone Won’t Save You Here’s a sweaty truth bomb: Chugging a gallon of plain water before class doesn’t equal “hydrated.” In fact, overhydrating with water and *not enough sodium* can lead to what we call hyponatremia —a fancy way to say, you diluted your blood like a too-weak protein shake, and now your cells are confused and cranky. You need electrolytes —specifically: - Sodium (the MVP) - Potassium (the sidekick) - Magnesium & Calcium (the underrated supporting cast) These minerals keep your muscles firing, your heart beating, and your brain sharp enough to count rounds even during Fran. Warning Signs You’re Not Hydrating Right Most people don’t recognize dehydration until they’re in the hurt locker. Don’t be that person. Watch for these red flags: - A sudden drop in performance or energy - Cramps out of nowhere (you weren’t even sprinting!) - Headaches, nausea, or lightheadedness - Your sweat smells unusually salty (gross but important) - You haven’t peed in hours—or it’s a lovely shade of neon yellow And no, “I had coffee this morning” doesn’t count. That’s like saying you had soup to hydrate. Nice try. Fix It Fast: Your Hydration Game Plan So how do you avoid training like a crusty raisin this summer? Step 1: Preload Like a Pro - 2–3 hours before training: drink 16–20 oz of water with a pinch of salt or a hydration packet. - 30 minutes before training: sip 6–8 oz more—don’t chug like you’re at a frat party. Step 2: Hydrate Like It’s a Strategy - During long or intense workouts (especially outside), sip water mixed with electrolytes. - Aim for about 1 liter per hour , more if you’re a heavy sweater. > Sweating buckets? You might need 700–1,000mg of sodium/hour. That’s not a typo. Step 3: Replace What You Lost The best way to know? Weigh yourself before and after a workout. For every pound lost , drink 20–24 oz of fluid plus electrolytes. (It’s not just for endurance athletes—we’re all salty, sweaty humans in July.) The Cold Hard Truth (That Might Surprise You) You don’t need fancy IV therapy or overpriced wellness elixirs. You need a hydration routine that fits your body, your training intensity, and the heat. Simple? Yes. Easy? Not always. But worth it? Absolutely. Hydration isn’t about sipping water—it’s about fueling recovery, avoiding heatstroke, and getting the most out of your hard work. Because nothing’s more frustrating than your training being wrecked by something you could have handled with a shaker bottle and a pinch of salt. One Last Nugget Before You Go Think of summer like a boss level in your training game. The sun is the final boss. The heat is its minions. And your secret weapon? Smart hydration. So before your next workout, don’t just fill your bottle— fill your strategy. Train smart. Sweat smart. And never let the heat win.
Imagine this: You’ve been crushing your workouts. You’re eating real food, lifting heavier each week, and your clothes feel looser. You step on the scale, expecting fireworks—and it spits back the same stubborn number you saw last week. Cue the spiraling: "Why am I even doing this?" Sound familiar? Here’s the truth: The scale is a terrible narrator of your transformation story. It’s like watching a blockbuster movie with the sound off—you’re missing everything that matters. It’s time to shift your focus. Because if you’re still treating the bathroom scale like the all-knowing oracle of progress, you’re setting yourself up for frustration instead of results. Let’s break this down. The Scale is a One-Trick Pony We’ve been trained to believe the scale is the ultimate judge: If it goes down, you’re “winning.” If it goes up, clearly you’ve made a blood pact with carbs and failed as a human. But here’s what the scale doesn’t tell you: - That you gained 3 pounds of muscle and dropped 2 pounds of fat - That your stress is lower, your sleep is better, and your lifts are going up - That you’re standing taller, breathing deeper, and feeling like a badass The number you see is just your gravitational relationship to the Earth. Not your worth. Not your success. And definitely not your future. Weight is Not the Same as Fat Let’s talk science for a hot second. Your weight fluctuates daily—sometimes wildly —based on: - Water retention (hello salty takeout) - Hormone shifts (yep, those too) - Glycogen storage (aka: how much fuel is in your muscles) - How sore you are (inflammation adds water weight) - Whether you pooped (no joke—this can swing your weight 1-2 pounds) So if you’re stepping on the scale and expecting it to deliver a precise, reliable signal of fat loss? That’s like using a Magic 8-Ball to plan your financial future. What Actually Shows Progress So what should you be paying attention to instead? 1. Progress Photos Photos don't lie—but they do surprise you. Take them in the same lighting, same outfit, same angle every couple of weeks. You’ll notice: - Waistlines shrinking - Muscles you didn’t know existed - A face that starts smiling back with more confidence Don’t trust your daily mirror. It sees you too often to notice the slow magic. 2. Strength and Performance Gains Can you: - Deadlift more than last month? - Do a full push-up where you used to do them from your knees? - Make it through a tough metcon without feeling like your lungs are on fire? These are massive wins. These are the real receipts of your effort. 3. Energy, Sleep, and Mood Write these down weekly—yes, actually write them. - Are you waking up rested? - Do you need less caffeine to survive your day? - Are your moods less chaotic and unpredictable? These may sound intangible, but they are trackable—and they point directly to improved health. 4. Clothing Fit A tape measure is great. But sometimes, your favorite jeans tell you everything you need to know. - Are they sliding on easier? - Less muffin-top? - Are shirts fitting your shoulders instead of your belly? That’s body recomposition, baby. Why This Matters (Like, Really Matters) Most people quit their fitness journey not because it’s hard… …but because they think it’s not working. When your only metric is a cheap scale, you’re giving all the power to a tool that doesn’t even understand your goals. Let that sink in. You’re training to be strong, capable, energetic, and confident—and you’re letting a $20 piece of plastic tell you whether you’re succeeding? Nah. Not anymore. How to Ditch the Scale and Do it Right If you’re ready to flip the script, here’s your action plan: Week 1: - Take progress photos from front, side, and back - Start a workout log (write down what you lifted or how you felt) - Write a weekly reflection: sleep, mood, energy (scale 1–5) Week 2 and Beyond: - Compare photos every 2–4 weeks - Watch strength go up and workouts feel easier - Track non-scale wins: “My knees didn’t hurt during squats today!” is GOLD. Final Word: You’re Not a Number If you take nothing else from this post, take this: The scale is a snapshot. Real progress is a documentary. You’re becoming someone stronger, more resilient, and more confident— even if the number doesn’t budge. So, take the pressure off the scale. Start tracking your real wins. And watch how fast your body—and mindset—start to change.
There are two kinds of people in this world: There’s Carol—and then there’s everyone else. When Carol joined our gym over four years ago, she was already a powerhouse in her own right: a dedicated runner with her sights set on a massive goal—completing marathons in all 50 states. There was just one catch: a nagging hip issue she knew would eventually require surgery. But that didn’t stop her. Carol would limp into the gym, finish a workout, limp back out, and go run another marathon. She was relentless—and completely unshakable in her commitment to her goal. And when we say relentless, we mean it: while most would hit pause at the sign of chronic pain, Carol just adjusted and kept going. Along the way, she didn’t just attend our regular group classes—she showed up for workshops, competitions, nutrition coaching, and even our community events. She also plays hockey. Ice hockey. All while managing the unique challenges of being a vegetarian and a Type 1 diabetic. Together, we’ve worked to fine-tune her nutrition—making sure she gets enough protein, stays hydrated, and feels energized for both running and training. Her resilience is unmatched. Carol eventually crossed that final finish line—her 50th state marathon—and then finally scheduled her hip replacement. But as life would have it, the first surgery didn’t go well. Less than a year later, she had to go back in for a second. And still… she came back. Just ten days post-op, Carol sent us an email: “I’m ready. I FINALLY got cleared from the doctor.” She was back. In class. Climbing ropes. Moving forward. Carol has faced setback after setback, but she’s never let them define her. She’s proof that real strength is more than muscle—it’s mindset. It’s showing up, again and again, even when things get hard. Especially when things get hard. And she’s paying it forward. Carol’s brought in friends—especially fellow runners—because she gets it: running alone won’t sustain you forever. Strength matters. Muscle matters. Independence, health, and longevity require more than endurance. They require training. Today, she still trains with us regularly, inspires others daily, and brings her signature energy to every challenge and partner workout. Carol will outwork anyone in the room—and she’ll encourage you the whole way. She’s what this community is all about.
